Squaring Circles Counselling

Counselling in Chesterfield & Online

How the impact of parental divorce on the child carries through to adulthood

Schematic impact - marital breakdown on the developing child

As a child I became a ‘fallout’ victim of domestic abuse subject to collateral damage, although at the time it wasn't considered to be such a detrimental issue. It was the early 70’s, and times were different, with specific attitudes that were unrecognised and perhaps almost defined as something that in many families was ‘not’ necessarily unusual.

And yet my life journey has shown that the effects were actually quite traumatic, with multiple manifestations of behavioural responses, reactions, moods, indeed my overall decision-making process, all being affected by what I witnessed and experienced from, and by, my parents marital demise; the verbal violence, a changing environment, a dysfunctional world affected by class and financial instability.

Overriding all these aspects, the internal conflict between what was sociologically promoted as a domestic utopia, a comforting role model that was all I should have known (or at least, sometimes, I believed that I did), imploding as a result of the family breakdown. Legacies that I have carried for well over fifty years.

It has taken a lifetime to establish some protection, needing the development of relationships, work, significant others, and life changing events. Ultimately the realisation and importance of recognising not only who I am but learning how to create the ‘positive from the negative’ and hopefully conclude the purpose of my past.

In many ways, the experience of providing therapy, rather than needing it personally (although beneficial and enlightening) introduces perspective. And yet, it is a veneer that constantly requires a re-varnish.

It never goes away, historic episodes that have a longevity of influences, affecting and impacting situations that have occurred throughout my life, and still do so to this day. The trials and tribulations faced during the progression of my mother’s vascular dementia became a classic example, symptomatic and symbolic of childhood exposure. The realisation of how we behave becomes secondary to the immediate circumstance. Inevitably, what we all ‘say and do’, as bystanders or significant players, leaves a residual template.

Of course, it hasn’t always been a solitary endeavour; siblings and wider family have also had to contemplate their own personal responses. But I knew at the time that the steps I took were influenced by my past, and how I dealt with those situations touched upon several maladaptive schemas, coping modes, (good and bad), and the association of surrender, avoidance, or overcompensation. Ultimately, a theory with practical ramifications that hijacked my existence.

It's not about blame. So many times, misunderstanding comments; “you have to move on”, ‘you cannot keep saying it’s all down to your parents”. But that misses the point.

“A recent review of 18 UK and international studies supported this conclusion that parental divorce was associated with an increased long-term risk of depression in their adult offspring (Sands et al 2017). A recent review of 18 UK and international studies supported this conclusion that parental divorce was associated with an increased long-term risk of depression in their adult offspring (Sands et al 2017)” (Harry Benson; Stephen McKay, 2017).
So, it isn’t that easy to ignore.

Of course, there any many different aspects, although inevitably it becomes a ‘sum of all the parts’. Yet, each contributing factor leaves its mark like a stamp of torture – a strong word but the following will hopefully define and explain (the sequence of events does not suggest a natural progression – its purpose is to reflect how individual personality has been influenced).

1. Divorce

Personal

When it happened, I was a child, not yet a teenager, and I clearly struggled with the knowledge that as a family unit, we were broken. Retrospectively, I can conclude that it was shame and embarrassment, perhaps an element of fear. I recall at the time being asked by fellow pupils why I was going a different way home; I couldn’t answer and nervously avoided the question (I also remember being afraid of my parents meeting, anticipating the arguments).

Maladaptive Schema – Abandonment; Emotional Deprivation; Shame

Clear then that my secure attachment was affected, resulting in a sense of the ‘vulnerable’ child (I don’t think I feel ‘shame now’, so perhaps not a developed maladaptive schema, although I certainly felt humiliation and became quite reserved).

My therapist, when discussing this in relation to current events, asked me ‘why’ I don’t ‘change this’, just ‘move on’. But I cannot erase the past, nor really transform how I currently deal with the stakeholders (it has a legacy that affects the dynamic across multiple relatives). But the acceptance and recognition helps – clearly, I’m not losing my mind, have justification for what I ‘say and do’, and fortunately, and thankfully, have learned that art has become my coping strategy. It has driven the creative slant, the power of words, and the melody of music, and in some way has given me the opportunity to rescript what has previously taken place. Perhaps, a greater understanding and acceptance, so much that at times I feel like the ‘wise old owl’!

Research

“Research has documented that parental divorce/separation is associated with an increased risk for child and adolescent adjustment problems, including academic difficulties (e.g., lower grades and school dropout), disruptive behaviours (e.g., conduct and substance use problems), and depressed mood. Offspring of divorced/separated parents are also more likely to engage in risky sexual behaviour, live in poverty, and experience their own family instability. Risk typically increases by a factor between 1.5 and 2. Still, most children whose parents divorce are resilient and exhibit no obvious psychological problems. It is important to recognize, however, that even resilient young people from divorced families often report painful feelings or encounters, such as worrying about events like graduations or weddings when both parents will be present.” (Brian D'Onofrio & Robert Emery, 2019)

2. Arguments

Personal

I was a spectator of confrontation during both my parent’s marriage to each other, and then within their successive ‘follow up’ relationships. Although the abuse was more verbal, I physically saw the non-verbal threats, aggressive gesticulations, and conflicts taking place across the dining table. Often voices shouting loudly in the middle of the night and, fearful of the outcome, I tried to both lose and save myself in sleep. It wasn’t easy, not surprising that I sometimes placed cotton wool in my ears to try and mask the pain.

Maladaptive Schema – Vulnerability; Subjugation.

The legacy of this is an avoidance of arguments. To see, hear, be a recipient of; any can create a sense of fear and dread which I avoid ‘like the plague’. Something in my psyche has infected my brain cells. Perhaps I coped at the time by becoming detached, which as an adult has (within my earlier adult life) pushed me towards compliant surrender.

Research

“The consequences of this can go in a couple of directions. They may copy this behaviour directly and learn to become fairly argumentative themselves, being quick to anger and defensiveness or refusing to listen to opinions contrary to their own. They may raise their voice a lot and come to see working out differences as a case of who wins, always trying to hold the upper hand in adult relationships rather than approach disagreements as a conversation or truly appreciate their partner's point of view. Alternatively, they may become very avoidant of conflict, so tired or even traumatised by their parents constant arguing that disagreements with other people may create a sense of real panic in them. They may shut off when they sense that an argument could be coming, as an adult freezing their partner out or just refusing to engage point blank.” (Relate, n.d.)

3. Impact

Personal

Easier for me now to ‘look back’ and understand more of how and why my mother had to leave my father, but not so easy for me to accept her being intimate, especially kissing her new partner (whilst I was present).
I remember my tears, my frustration, and although I cannot recall what I said to mum, I know I was visibly upset and at that specific moment felt protective for dad; almost ‘sorry’ for him even though I believed him to be the perpetrator.

Many years later, I probably understood more of the dynamic between my parents, to the extent that I realised that their relationship wasn’t as ‘black and white’ as I originally viewed it to be.

Several years after their divorce, and still feeling the reverberations of the marital breakdown (one of the things I was instructed to do was ask Dad for maintenance, something that was awkward to ask for especially as it wasn’t welcomed by my stepmother), dad and stepmum had a violent argument that lasted throughout the night. The next day, too drunk to drive, dad somehow coerced me to get in his car with the intention of driving me back to mum. I was young, and I suppose I did as he asked because he was my dad. Intoxicated he drove the wrong way around a roundabout, fortunately stopping at traffic lights where I quickly escaped and caught the bus home. A horrendous experience.

Throughout all this, I was closely attached to my mother. Dad was never paternal; he was a shy man and couldn’t show his affection. All his life, the only way he could demonstrate his love was giving money, notes always rolled up in his top pocket from which he would dole out the cash. Not surprising that I was tied to my mother’s apron strings, always the baby and mollycoddled without exception. I think I missed her so much, probably one of the reasons why I was so affected by her kissing the man who was to become my new stepfather (I recall him asking my mother why I wanted to go shopping with her and not go out and play with the kids from the village).

Maladaptive Schema – Abandonment; Mistrust; Emotional Deprivation; Defectiveness and Shame; Social Isolation; Dependence; Vulnerability; Enmeshment; Failure; Pessimism; emotional inhibition.

Research

“Frequent, intense and poorly resolved conflict between parents can place children at risk of mental health issues, and behavioural, social and academic problems. It can also have a significant effect on a child’s long-term outcomes. There is a strong body of evidence to show how damaging inter-parental conflict can harm children’s outcomes (even when parents manage to sustain positive parent-child relationship), put children at more risk of having problems with school and learning, negative peer relationships, physical health problems, smoking and substance misuse and mental health and wellbeing challenges. The risks can also have an effect on long-term life outcomes such as poor future relationship chances, reduced academic attainment, lower employability, heightened interpersonal violence, and depression and anxiety. Evidence on the impact of parental conflict on children shows that where a child lives with both parents in the same household, more than 1 in 10 (12%) children have at least one parent who reports relationship distress. Previous research (2017) identified that children living in workless families are twice as likely to experience parental conflict than in families where both parents are in work”. (Gov.UK, 2021).

Conclusion

Of course, although this blog is reflective of my personal experience, and ultimately how I make sense of all that I was exposed to, personal therapy has also highlighted a degree of attachment theory, schematic responses, and how, why, and when I react in specific situations. The plethora of research comments available suggests that the outcome is probably detrimental for the child, and some of the references here exemplify that fact. And yet, can there be a positive?

It would be easy, therefore (although time consuming) to analyse every aspect of my motivation, life choices, personality traits, behavioural actions, and potentially discover an association to what I witnessed many years ago. And yet, one has to also take responsibility for those later lifestyle choices and cannot always lay the condition ‘at the door of one’s parents’. It is, indeed, a life lesson.
I am by no means perfect, but as a parent I am probably the opposite of all what my mother and father demonstrated, Yet, to give them due compliment and recognition, they probably didn’t know any better, it was always delivered with the best of intentions, and importantly, love. Ultimately, that is what has probably kept me on the ‘straight and narrow’.

Research

“Compared with children growing up in intact families, outcomes across a range of measures are poorer for children who experience family breakdown, and some of these persist into adulthood. For example, they are less likely to gain educational qualifications, and more likely to leave home and become a parent at a younger age. The differences, however, are comparatively small, with many children not affected, and most children are not adversely affected in the long term. Some children benefit from parental separation, particularly children who have witnessed or been subject to violence and abuse or living in households where there were high levels of parental conflict. The review has shown that dimensions of family functioning and some socio-economic factors have a greater influence than family structure on child well-being. Financial hardship and poor or disrupted parenting have a negative impact on outcomes for children growing up in intact as well as separated families. It is therefore important to avoid the risk of stigmatising certain family forms, such as single parent families, and to focus instead on the underlying mechanisms that contribute to poorer outcomes for children. Recent research stresses that family breakdown should be understood as a process and not a single event. Evidence shows that a number of key factors contribute to, and/or are a consequence of, family breakdown. Among these, the most significant are financial hardship, poor maternal mental health, and protracted and unresolved conflict between parents. These factors interact in complex ways and, via a chain of events, have a cumulative effect. Typically, they lead to increased stress on the part of the custodial parent (usually mothers)
which, in turn, increases the risk of negative outcomes in children. However, positive maternal mental health and mothers’ access to adequate social and financial support serve to moderate the potentially negative impact of family breakdown on children. Good communication between parents, and positive child-parent relationships are crucial to children’s well-being. Parents who are able to contain their distress and to negotiate and facilitate acceptable arrangements post-separation also help their children to adjust to family breakdown. The findings highlight the dynamic nature of change in contemporary family life. Divorce and parental separation are more common than they once were, and an initial experience of family breakdown often heralds further changes, including those in family structure. Increasingly, children and parents are required to develop the necessary coping skills to adjust to repeated transitions in family form. In this context, it will be important for public policy to acknowledge the realities of family life and to adopt strategies that support parents in the task of parenting and to enhance those factors that have been shown to reduce the potentially negative effects of parental separation.” (Ann Mooney;Chris Oliver;Marjorie Smith, 2009)


© Squaring Circles Counselling

powered by WebHealer